Is 93% of communication really nonverbal?

Short answer: no. The 93% figure comes from two experiments on how people interpreted positive or negative feelings when words conflicted with vocal tone or facial expression. It is not a measurement of how much of every conversation is nonverbal.

A presenter speaking to a group in a lecture room

Original studies

In the 1960s Albert Mehrabian conducted 2 studies around inconsistency in communication.

He wanted to research things like eg. saying “I’m very happy”, but with a sad face. Will most people think the person is happy or sad? How much of their decision making will depend on words, tone of voice or facial expression?

Both studies focused on the communication of positive or negative emotions via single spoken words, like "dear" or "terrible". The first study compared the relative importance of the semantic meaning of the word with the tone of voice, and found that the latter was much more influential. The second study dealt with facial expressions (shown in black-and-white photographs) and vocal tone (as heard in a tape recording), and found that the relative contributions of the two communication channels had the ratio 3:2. Mehrabian then combined the results of the two studies to obtain the ratio 7:38:55.

Further research

The findings were interesting, but relative to very specific conditions and thus the studies received plenty of criticism - judging based on single words instead of whole conversations, judging based on photographs instead of videos, comparing only positive versus negative emotions.

Since then, other researchers tried to convey similar experiments, while addressing these concerns. One experiment from 1970 suggested body language was ~4 times more influential than spoken words. On the other hand, another study from 1992 showed that hardly anyone can communicate with just body language and without any words, which isn’t very surprising.

Professor Mehrabian also clearly stated in his papers that the "7%-38%-55% rule" was derived from experiments dealing with communications of feelings and attitudes (i.e. like–dislike), so not any communication.

Practicality

When I give a conference talk in a dark auditorium, I’m well aware that people are mostly paying attention to my words and slides, but very little to my body language.

In casual conversations at shops or work, I notice that words can seem to matter less than tone and expression.

In everyday conversation, body language can matter, though its role varies with context and relationships. It’s definitely worth paying attention to your body language, but giving it 90% importance will be too much in most of the situations.